Two commercial mortgage offers can carry the same interest rate and still cost thousands of pounds apart. The difference usually sits in the fees: what is charged, when it is charged, whether it is added to the loan and how long the borrower keeps the mortgage. A rate on its own tells you what you will pay each month or year in interest, but it says nothing about what it costs to get the loan in place, hold it and eventually leave it.
This guide looks at how fees feed into the real cost of borrowing, why the same fee can be good value on one deal and poor value on another, and how to compare offers on a sensible basis.
Interest is the most visible cost, so it tends to dominate the conversation. Fees sit alongside it and affect the total in three ways. They add to the upfront cash needed to complete, they can increase the amount borrowed if they are added to the loan, and they can come back at the end through charges for repaying early.
A lender with a lower rate may charge higher fees to make up the difference, and the reverse is also true. The combination matters, and the right one depends on how long you expect to hold the loan. A higher fee spread over a ten-year fixed term costs far less per year than the same fee on a loan you refinance after two.
The cost of arranging and holding a commercial mortgage is usually made up of several charges, and it helps to separate those that go to the lender from those that go to others.
On the lender side, the main charge is the arrangement fee, sometimes called a product or facility fee, usually calculated as a percentage of the loan. In some structures there is also a commitment fee, charged for holding funds available, and an exit or redemption fee at the end of the term. Early repayment charges can apply if you repay or refinance before an agreed period ends.
Third-party costs include the valuation fee, legal costs for both sides, and any additional items such as a monitoring surveyor on a refurbishment or insurance requirements. If you use a broker, there may be a broker fee, or the broker may be paid a commission by the lender, and either arrangement should be disclosed to you in writing.
Each of these varies by lender, property and transaction, so there is no reliable universal figure. The relevant numbers are the ones in your own quotes and offer.
Where a fee is paid matters as much as how large it is. There are broadly three routes, and each affects the cost differently.
If fees are paid in cash at the outset, you need the funds available and they do not accrue interest. If they are deducted from the loan advance, you receive less than the headline amount and may need to find the shortfall elsewhere, particularly on a purchase. If they are added to the loan, you do not need the cash up front, but you pay interest on the added amount for as long as the loan lasts, and your loan-to-value ratio rises slightly.
Adding a fee to the loan is therefore a form of borrowing against it. On a short loan the extra interest is small, while on a long one it can add up. This is one of the less obvious ways a fee increases the overall cost, and it is worth asking the lender to show the effect rather than assuming it is negligible.
Consider a £500,000 loan that the borrower expects to keep for five years, with two simplified offers.
Offer A has a lower interest rate and a 2% arrangement fee, which is £10,000. Offer B has a slightly higher rate and a 1% fee, which is £5,000. The £5,000 difference in fees is paid at the start. The question is whether Offer A’s lower rate saves more than £5,000 across the five years.
If the rate difference saves a little over £1,000 a year in interest, Offer A breaks even at around the five-year point, and anything beyond that favours it. If the borrower instead plans to refinance after two years, Offer A’s higher fee will not have been recovered, and Offer B would have been cheaper. I have kept the actual rates out of the example because they depend on the market and the lender, and the point is the method rather than the numbers.
This kind of break-even thinking is the most practical tool available. Work out the total of fees plus interest across the period you realistically expect to hold the loan, then compare offers on that total.
Many commercial borrowers do not keep a loan for its full term. Fixed-rate periods often run for two, three, five or ten years, and a business may sell, refinance or restructure before then. The shorter your likely holding period, the more weight upfront fees carry, because there is less time to recover them through a lower rate.
The other side of this is the cost of leaving. If a loan has early repayment charges, repaying before the end of the fixed period can add a substantial cost, and that needs to be weighed against the benefit of whatever you are moving to. A product with low upfront fees but heavy early repayment charges can look attractive on day one and turn out expensive if your plans change. Ask for the early repayment schedule at the outset and work out what it would cost to leave at each stage.
Several charges are easy to miss when comparing quotes, and they can shift the picture. Legal fees are usually paid to two firms, yours and the lender’s, and they rise with the complexity of the transaction. Valuation fees are generally payable upfront and are rarely refundable if the deal fails. Some lenders charge for administration at completion, bank transfers or variations to the loan during its term.
There is also the cost of a deal that does not complete. Fees paid on application or acceptance, such as valuation, some legal costs and in some cases part of the lender’s fee, may be lost if the transaction falls through. That risk does not appear in a simple comparison of rates, but it is real, and it is worth asking each lender which charges are refundable and which are not.
How a borrower’s income is evidenced can affect which lenders are available, and that in turn affects the fees on offer. Business owners with variable income or recent changes in structure may find a narrower range of products, and sometimes a higher cost, than those with straightforward accounts. Anyone in that position might find advice such as Self-Employed Mortgage Advice Grays useful before applying, since presenting income clearly can widen the choices and make the comparison of costs more meaningful, though no outcome can be guaranteed and each lender decides on its own criteria.
A useful comparison puts every offer on the same basis. List every charge for each, who it is paid to, when it is due, whether it is refundable and how it is paid. Then add the interest over your expected holding period and include the cost of leaving, if you may repay early.
A simple table of your own making, with a column for each offer, usually shows quickly which deal is cheaper over the period that matters. It also shows where an apparently small fee has a large effect, and where a high headline fee is outweighed by a lower rate. If a lender or broker cannot give you a clear breakdown, that is itself a useful piece of information.
For those who have only dealt with residential borrowing, looking at how a first time buyer mortgage basildon is structured can help, because the same elements of product fees, valuation, legal costs and early repayment apply, only on a smaller scale and with fewer variations than in commercial lending.
Before you commit, it is worth putting a short set of questions to each lender or broker. What are all the fees, and which are paid to the lender and which to others? Are any added to the loan, and if so, what is the interest effect over the term? Which fees are refundable if the deal does not complete? What early repayment or exit charges apply and how do they fall over time? And how long do you expect to keep the loan, since that determines which of these costs matters most?
The interest rate tells you part of the story, and the fees tell you the rest. Compare offers on the total cost over the period you realistically expect to hold the loan, include what it would cost to leave, and make sure every charge is set out in writing before you accept. If the numbers are close, the structure of the fees and the flexibility to repay will often decide which deal suits you better.